Saturday Afternoon Program
| 84. Symposium: Saturday, 12:00 - 1:20
Grand B |
Developing and Using Competency Models in Government Organizations
With the challenges to increase productivity and efficiency, government organizations
have started to develop and use competency models to update their personnel systems to be
better aligned with business goals. This symposium describes how competency modeling is
conducted and implemented in different applied government or quasi-government agencies.
Laura Ackerman Steighner, US Postal Service, Chair
Deborah L. Whetzel, US Postal Service, William Bruker, US Postal Service, Michael
Patsfall, US Postal Service,
Laura Ackerman Steighner, US Postal Service, Development of the United States Postal
Service Executive
Competency Model
Suzanne Tsacoumis, HumRRO, Sheila R. Schultz, HumRRO, Darlene Olson, Federal
Aviation Administration, The
Development of a
Generic Competency Model
David M. Pollack, US Immigration & Naturalization Service, The Use of a
Competency-Based Assessment Model
Donna Rodriguez, US Office of Personnel Management, Donna Gregory, US Office of
Personnel Management,
Rita Patel, US Office
of Personnel Management, Competency Based Personnel System for the District of
Columbia
Richard J. Klimoski, George Mason University, Discussant
| 85. Panel Discussion: Saturday, 12:00 - 1:20
Senators |
Survey-Guided Organizational Development: What Works and What
Doesnt
An extensive literature exists on designing and administering organizational surveys.
There is comparatively less attention in the literature on uses of survey results in
organizations. This panel discussion will address design of procedures to maximize the
value of survey data, linkage to strategic management and planning, and avoiding common
pitfalls.
Robert J. Vance, Pennsylvania State University, Chair
Karl W. Kuhnert, University of Georgia, Panelist
Scott M. Brooks, Gantz Wiley Research, Panelist
Alan L. Colquitt, Eli Lilly & Company, Panelist
Randy Marcy, Federal Law Enforcement Training Center, Panelist
| 86. Symposium: Saturday, 12:00 - 1:20
Peacock Terrace |
Refining the Role of Dispositions: Time, Level, Specificity, and
Interactions
This symposium emphasizes the substantive role of dispositions in the work place. We
use greater construct specificity to consider how dispositions operate over time, across
levels of analysis, and in interaction with job characteristics. These results refine the
role that dispositions play in organizations.
Peter M. Hart, University of Melbourne, Chair
Peter M. Hart, University of Melbourne, Cary Cooper, University of Manchester, Time
Specificity and the
Substantive Nature of
Negative Affectivity
Mark Griffin, University of Queensland, Peter M. Hart, University of Melbourne,
Melinda Norris, University of
Melbourne, Alexander
Wearing, University of Melbourne, Individual Dispositions and Reactions to
Work: Differences
Across Work Groups
Suzy Fox, University of South Florida, Paul Spector, University of South Florida, Anger
and Anxiety as
Predictors of
Counterproductive Behavior
Sharon Parker, University of Sheffield, Christine Sprigg, University of Sheffield,
Work Design and Well-Being:
The Role of Proactive
Personality
Lois E. Tetrick, University of Houston, Discussant
| 87. Symposium: Saturday, 12:00 - 1:20
Metropolitan |
Interviewing: What are we Measuring?
Recent research appears to have shifted from validity studies toward a broader view of
what interviews measure. This symposium examines broad trends of what interviews measure,
the factor structure of interview ratings, the relationship between non-verbal behavior
and job performance, and the impact of researcher motivation on results.
Philip L. Roth, Clemson University, Chair
Richard Posthuma, Purdue University, Frederick Morgeson, Purdue University,
Michael A. Campion, Purdue
University, Research
on the Employment Interview: Current Trends and Future Directions
Allen I. Huffcutt, Bradley University, Philip L. Roth, Clemson University, James
M. Conway, Seton Hall
University, Employment
Interview Constructs: A Factor Analytic Approach
Timothy G. DeGroot, Catholic University, Stephan J. Motowidlo, University of
Florida, What Is Being Measured
in the Interview:
Explaining the Effects of Nonverbal Cues
Craig J. Russell, University of Oklahoma, M. Ronald Buckley, University of
Oklahoma, Michelle A. Dean,
University of Oklahoma,
Danielle Wiese, University of Oklahoma, An Examination of Relationship
Between Investigator
Motivation and Criterion-Related Validities for Employment Interviews
Patrick M. Wright, Cornell University, Discussant
| 88. Symposium: Saturday, 12:00 - 1:20
Monet |
Image is Everything? Corporate Image and Applicant Attraction
Presented are attempts at understanding the determinants of corporate image and the
impact corporate image may have on applicant attraction. The symposium represents diverse
perspectives, ranging from assessments of person-organization fit to tactics of influence
and persuasion. Moreover, diverse populations are sampled, including teenagers, Black
engineers, college interviewees, and retired job seekers.
Scott Highhouse, Bowling Green State University, Chair
Daniel M. Cable, University of North Carolina, Lynda Aiman-Smith, North Carolina
State University, Paul W.
Mulvey, North Carolina
State University, Sources and Accuracy of Job Seekers Perceptions of
Organizational Culture
Peter D. Bachiochi, Bowling Green State University, Gwen G. Fisher, Bowling Green
State University,
Organizational
Attractiveness Among Black Engineering Students: The "NSBE 50"
Scott Highhouse, Bowling Green State University, Michael Zickar, Bowling Green
State University, Todd J.
Thorsteinson, Bowling
Green State University, Sandra Stierwalt, Bowling Green State University, Jerel
Slaughter, Bowling
Green State University, Company Employment Image in Fast Food: Perceptions of
Teenagers and Retirees
Anat Rafaeli, University of Michigan, Forming a Reputation in Organizational
Recruiting: Evidence from
Employment
Advertisements
Robert D. Gatewood, University of Georgia, Discussant
Andrea S. Goldberg, IBM, Discussant
| 89. Symposium: Saturday, 12:00 - 12:50
Obelisk A & B |
Job Knowledge: Explorations of its Conception, Description, and
Measurement
Although job knowledge is one of five major classes of constructs within I-O psychology
(KSAOs and job performance), it receives scarce research attention. This symposium
examines the nature of workplace expertise. Special emphasis is given to exploring
alternative conceptions, descriptions, and assessments of job knowledge, and their
implications for practice.
David A. DuBois, Psychological Systems and Research, Chair
Valerie Shalin, Wright State University, The Content and Functions of
Knowledge in the Analysis of Job
Expertise
Cathy L. Z. DuBois, Kent State University, David A. DuBois, Psychological Systems
and Research, Robert H.
Faley, Kent State
University, Acquisition of Machinist Expertise: Correlates of Self-Directed Learning
in the Workplace
Mary Ann Hanson, Personnel Decision Research Institutes, Kristen Horgen,
University of South Florida, Walter
C. Borman, University
of South Florida, Construct Validity Evidence for Measures of Situational
Judgment
David A. DuBois, Psychological Systems and Research, Cathy L. Z. DuBois, Kent
State University, The Role of
Expertise in Rater
Judgments
Robert G. Lord, University of Akron, Discussant
| 90. Master Tutorial: Saturday, 12:00 - 1:20
Rosetta |
The Measurement of Team Performance
The complexities of team performance measurement make it difficult to assess the value
of work team designs, as well as the impact of team training interventions. This master
tutorial presents guidelines and lessons learned from over 10 years of research aimed at
describing, evaluating, and diagnosing team performance.
Kimberly A. Smith-Jentsch, Naval Air Warfare Center, Chair
Janis Cannon-Bowers, Naval Air Warfare Center, Presenter
Eduardo Salas, Naval Air Warfare Center, Presenter
| 91. Symposium: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Grand A |
The Utility and Practical Value of Biodata
Practical results are presented from professionally conducted biodata research programs
in industry. On the whole the findings show that properly developed biodata have important
advantages including high utility for increasing productivity and decreasing turnover,
with less adverse impact, less invasiveness and greater job-relevance than personality and
ability tests.
Terry W. Mitchell, MPORT Management Solutions, Chair
Lawrence A. Witt, Barnett Bank, Validity and Impact of Biodata, Personality,
and Cognitive Ability Testing
William L. Farmer, University of Oklahoma, User Reaction to Biodata,
Personality, and Cognitive Ability Tests
Thomas L. Dallam, Circuit City Stores, Dennis L. Warmke, Circuit City Stores, Validation
of the Sales Counselor
Biodata Questionnaire
(SCBQ)
Robert E. Lewis, Payless Shoe Source, Terrence Guth, Payless Shoe Source, The
Practical Effects of Biodata on
Tenure at a Large
Retailer
John C. Callender, Procter & Gamble Company, Discussant
| 92. Symposium: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Grand D |
Measurement Issues in Job Analysis: Good News and Bad News
Collecting accurate and useful job analysis data has never been more important;
however, many measurement-related questions in job analysis remain unanswered. This
symposium reviews research involving task-, worker-, and ability-oriented job ratings, the
results of which provide cause for both optimism (regarding work dimensionality) and
concern (regarding reliability and validity).
Robert J. Harvey, Virginia Tech, Chair
Barbara B. Ellis, University of Texas at El Paso, Gabriela Guerrero, University of
Texas at El Paso,
Incumbent-Supervisor
Agreement on the Computer-Administered Common-Metric Questionnaire
Kristin Freund Murphy, North Carolina State University, Mark A. Wilson, North
Carolina State University, A
Comparison of Repeated
Items and Test-Retest Methods for Estimating the Reliability of Task and
KSA Ratings
Robert J. Harvey, Virginia Tech, Mark A. Wilson, North Carolina State University, Monte
Carlo Baselines for
Inter-Rater Agreement
when Rating KSA Requirements: How Much Is Enough?
Susana R. Lozada-Larsen, Larsen and Associates, Predicting National
Market-Wage Compensation Rates
Using the Common-Metric
Questionnaire: A Policy-Capturing Study
Leslie Thomas, ACT, Uncovering the Dimensionality of Work: Factor Analysis
Versus Multidimensional
Item-Response Theory
(MIRT)
Mark A. Wilson, North Carolina State University, Discussant
| 93. Symposium: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Grand E |
Job-Search and Reemployment Research Progress and Prospects
Millions of individuals look for a job each year. Unfortunately, we have a great deal
left to learn about the job-search process. This symposium involves presentations of
current work regarding the job-search process, and the psychological and demographic
variables associated with job-search intensity, persistence, and faster reemployment.
Connie Wanberg, University of Minnesota, Chair
Ruth Kanfer, Georgia Tech, Connie Wanberg, University of Minnesota, Job
Search: Conceptualizing the
Construct from a
Self-Regulation Perspective
Connie Wanberg, University of Minnesota, Ruth Kanfer, Georgia Tech, Maria Rotundo,
University of Minnesota,
The Role
of Motivation, Job-Search Self-Efficacy, and Situational Constraints in the Job-Search
Process
Alan M. Saks, York University, Blake Ashforth, Arizona State University, An
Examination of the Changes in
Job Search Emotions and
Behaviors of Unsuccessful Job Seekers
Angelo Kinicki, Arizona State University, Gregory E. Prussia, Seattle University, Pursuing
Reemployment after a
Plant Closing: A Test
of Competing Models
Amy Wrzesniewski, University of Michigan, The Relationship Between Work
Orientation and Job-Search
Activities in
Re-employment Outcomes
Carrie R. Leana, University of Pittsburgh, Discussant
| 94. Poster Session: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Chantilly East |
Culture, Socialization, and Leadership
94-1
Organizational Structure and Individual Outcomes: A Meta-Analysis
Mark Agars, Pennsylvania State University
Deidra J. Schleicher, Pennsylvania State University
Erika Ringseis, Pennsylvania State University
A review and meta-analysis of links between organizational structure and individual
outcome variables was conducted; several interesting sample and measurement moderators
were examined. Results suggest structure has important influences on individual outcomes;
particularly satisfaction, commitment, tenure, and role attitudes. Results are interpreted
in the context of the changing world of work.
94-2
Mentors Picking Protgs : Influences on Protg Selection
Tammy D. Allen, University of South Florida
Mark L. Poteet, City of Clearwater
Joyce E. A. Russell, University of Tennessee
This study examined protg characteristics mentors reported most influential when
choosing a protg. Results revealed mentors were more likely to choose a protg
based on the protgs ability than the protgs need for help and that
women were more likely to choose a protg based on the protgs ability than
were men.
94-3
Psychological and Organizational Climate Perceptions:
A Field Experiment of a Contemporary Distinction
Rob Altmann, Northern Illinois University
Joseph Huff, Northern Illinois University
Boris B. Baltes, Northern Illinois University
Heather A. LaCost, Northern Illinois University
Scott A. Young, Northern Illinois University
Chris P. Parker, Northern Illinois University
Distinctions between organizational and psychological climate have been made, but
minimally practiced. A contemporary approach was applied to this problem. Relationships
between two types of psychological climate and both previously examined and unexamined
outcome variables were explored in a novel organizationa not-for-profit,
nongovernment fitness and community service organization.
94-4
Service Climate, Service Type, and Owners Service Values in Small
Businesses
Tanya Andrews, Bowling Green State University
Steven Rogelberg, Bowling Green State University
This study examined the relationship among service climate, service type, and
owners service values in 25 small businesses. The hypothesized relationships between
service climate and the service type characteristics were confirmed. Regarding
owners service values and service climate, results were non-significant, yet
interestingly in the opposite direction of the hypothesis.
94-5
Followership, Leadership, and Attachment Styles: A Developmental
Approach
Yair Berson, SUNY-Binghamton
Francis J. Yammarino, SUNY-Binghamton
We investigated the relationships between followers attachment style, implicit
leadership and followership perceptions, perceptions of a group leader, and objective
performance. We found that implicit leadership perceptions predicted performance only for
securely-attached individuals. Insecurely-attached, as compared to securely-attached
individuals had nearly the opposite profiles of an ideal leader.
94-6
Manager Personality, Climate, Customer Satisfaction, and Productivity:
A Structural Model
S. Adam Boesen, University of Tulsa
Examines the links between managerial personality and commonly tracked outcome measures
such as unit productivity, customer satisfaction, and psychological climate. A theoretical
structural model is proposed and tested using data from a chain of convenience stores.
Results show weak support for the proposed model, and an alternate model is examined.
Suggestions are offered for future research.
94-7
Individual Difference Variables and Leadership Perceptions:
Linear or Catastrophic Relationship?
Doug Brown, University of Akron
Christopher Marchioro, University of Akron
James A. Tan, University of Akron
Robert G. Lord, University of Akron
Little research has examined how leadership perceptions evolve over time. The current
paper used cusp catastrophe modeling techniques and determined that perceptions of male
and female leaders evolve differentially (i.e., both continuously and abruptly) and that
these were a function of perceiver individual differences (i.e., leader self-schema and
gender).
94-8
Leadership and Organizational Decline:
Relationship Between Characteristics and Performance
David P. Costanza, George Washington University
The present study looked at leader personality traits that limit organizational
adaptation and lead to decline, and organizational characteristics that moderate this
relationship. Profiles of 110 corporate leaders were used to predict organizational
performance. Results showed that certain personality variables predicted negative
performance and were moderated by organizational structural variables.
94-9
Biodata, Interests, Values, and Achievement:
Predictors of Advanced Degree Attainment
Mary Alice Crowe-Taylor, University of Georgia
C. Douglas Johnson, University of Georgia
Adam Meade, University of Georgia
Amy Montagliani, University of Georgia
Garnett S. Stokes, University of Georgia
Robert D. Gatewood, University of Georgia
Adolescent life experiences, vocational interests, values and academic achievement were
used to predict advanced degree attainment 26 years later in a sample of 362 college
graduates. Multiple regressions were conducted. Most of the predictors were significant
for men but not for women. Vocational interests predicted better than academic
achievement.
94-10
Reconceptualizing the Entrepreneur: A Look at Portuguese Restaurant
Owners
Nancy Dasilva, University of Houston
Lois E. Tetrick, University of Houston
The present study surveyed 90 restaurant owners in Portugal. Using categorization
theory, the study predicted that entrepreneurs would frame business situations more
positively than would non-entrepreneurs. Several operational definitions of an
entrepreneur were used and the results differed depending on the type of operational
definition.
94-11
Differences in Within-Organization Agreement When Describing the
Organization and Implications of These Differences
Marcus W. Dickson, Wayne State University
Based on never-tested arguments of Burns and Stalker (1961), evidence is presented
suggesting that the level of within-organization agreement when describing organizational
policies and practices varies significantly between mechanistic and organic organizations.
These results suggest that random sampling across an organization may not provide an
accurate description of the organization.
94-12
When the Type of Move Matters:
Employees Reactions to Job-Related Relocation
Lillian T. Eby, University of Georgia
Jacquelyn DeMatteo, University of Tennessee
Post-move attitudes and intentions were examined. Employees who moved involuntarily
reported a weaker psychological contract and higher turnover intentions than those who
described their move as voluntary. Employees who made a lateral or downward job change
reported a weakened psychological contract and higher turnover intentions than those who
moved for a promotion.
94-13
Implanting Pygmalion Leadership Style Through Training:
Seven True Field Experiments
Dov Eden, Tel Aviv University
Seven field experiments evaluated training workshops designed to impart the Pygmalion
Leadership Style (PLS) to managers. PLS is manager behavior that conveys high performance
expectations to subordinates. Although the results were mixed, most of the experiments
showed little evidence that the training improved leadership or aroused much response
among subordinates.
94-14
Role of Social Integration in Career Advancement
Jacqueline A. Gilbert, Middle Tennessee State University
Deniz S. Ones, University of Minnesota
There is a paucity of research examining diversity management related variables in
organizations. The major question which this research examines is whether informal
integration is likely to result in career advancement and increased resource availability
in two different organizations in different stages of managing their diversity. Results
were consistent with hypotheses.
94-15
In the Eyes of the Beholder: Modeling Executive Effectiveness
Marilyn E. Gist, University of Washington
David Gerson, University of Washington
Multi-source evaluations were collected from 629 coworkers of 93 executives. A
structural equation model was developed for six predictors of executive effectiveness as
viewed by others. Perceptions of executives cognitive proficiency had the strongest
influence on ratings of executive effectiveness; positive interpersonal behaviors most
heavily influenced perceptions of cognitive proficiency.
94-16
Does Mentor-Protg Agreement on Mentor Leadership Style Influence the
Quality of Mentoring Relationships
Veronica Godshalk, Pennsylvania State University- Great Valley
John J. Sosik, Pennsylvania State University- Great Valley
This study examined the mentor-protg agreement regarding mentor transformational
leadership style and quality of mentoring relationship that existed. Mentors were
classified as over-estimators, under-estimators, or in-agreement, based on difference
between their self-rating and protgs rating of mentors transformational
leadership style. Under-estimator dyads experience the highest quality of mentoring
relationships.
94-17
Vertical Dyadic Linkage Theory: A Leadership Theory of Group Performance
Harold W. Goldstein, Baruch College
D. Brent Smith, University of Maryland
According to reviews of the literature (Yukl, 1989; Graen & Uhl-Bein, 1995),
Vertical Dyadic Linkage theory has failed to address the issue of work unit level
effectiveness, instead focusing at the individual level of analysis. In this paper, this
issue is addressed theoretically and a partial empirical test is presented.
94-18
The Role of Supportive Peers for Mentored and Nonmentored Individuals
Kristen M. Haggis, University of Connecticut
Janet L. Barnes-Farrell, University of Connecticut
An instrument to measure the career and psychosocial functions provided by peers was
developed. Functions provided by supportive peers to mentored and nonmentored individuals
were compared. Protgs perceived that their peers provided significantly more
psychosocial functions than those without mentors. Peers age and power differed
significantly for the two groups.
94-19
Structural Equation Modeling Approaches to Understanding
Leader-Member Dyadic Relationships
Rosalie J. Hall, University of Akron
Jeann Makiney, University of Akron
Christopher Marchioro, University of Akron
Robert G. Lord, University of Akron
Elaine M. Engle, Federal Bureau of Investigation
This paper demonstrates three structural equation modeling techniques of use in the
analysis of data sets with potential dyad- and individual-level components: (a)
decomposition of correlations into dyad- and individual-level components, (b) equivalence
of within- and cross-person paths, and (c) mediator models with cross-person paths.
94-20
An Examination of Qualities Associated with Leadership Judgments
of Various Rater Groups
Jeff Harper, Georgia Tech
Todd J. Maurer, Georgia Tech
This study utilized 360-degree assessment ratings to investigate which factors drive
leadership perceptions for the different rater groups. Results indicated that
"leadership" is defined differently by different rater groups, and that rater
confidence in rating accuracy moderated the degree to which factors were thought to drive
leadership perceptions.
94-21
Personality and Leadership: Machiavellian but not Destructive
Anne E. Holloway, Virginia Tech
Daniel P. Russell, Virginia Tech
Sigrid B. Gustafson, Virginia Tech
The present studies demonstrate that individuals high in Machiavellianism (Machs;
Christie 1970) may be cool manipulators but do not exhibit the destructive tendencies
usually attributed to this personality construct. In contrast, aberrant self-promotion has
been proposed as the personality construct encompassing both manipulation and
destructiveness. Results support this proposition.
94-22
Using the Internet for Competitive Advantage
Ann W. Howell, Michigan State University
Morell E. Mullins, Michigan State University
Sandra L. Fisher, Personnel Decision Research Institutes
Neal W. Schmitt, Michigan State University
Steve W. J. Kozlowski, Michigan State University
This study surveyed 169 professionals to determine situational and individual variables
predicting adoption and implementation of electronic information gathering sources (i.e.,
the Internet). Results indicate that situational variables explain 44% of the variance in
use of electronic data gathering while individual difference variables explain virtually
no variance.
94-23
Job Satisfaction, Employee Withdrawal, and an Enjoyable Work Environment
Steven T. Hunt, Saville & Holdsworth Ltd
Scott A. Goodman, Saville & Holdsworth Ltd.
Joel Quintela, The Ohio State University
Small correlations between job satisfaction and behavior may result from
conceptualizing job satisfaction in terms of individual employee attitudes, rather than as
the reflection of "enjoyable work environments." Correlations between
organizational-level measures of job satisfaction and employee withdrawal exceed .50.
Creating enjoyable work environments may have substantial "bottom line" impact.
94-24
Organizational Culture and Performance: A Study of A Franchise System
Svetlana V. Ivanitskaya, Central Michigan University
Analyses of organizational culture of a franchise system indicated that differences in
unit cultures were more pronounced for practices than for shared values. Little evidence
was found that strong cultures perform better or that older organizations have stronger
cultures. Lazears idea that larger organizations have weaker cultures was partially
supported.
94-25
A Model of Leadership Effectiveness in Professional Service Firms
Miriam W. Javitch, Columbia University
Ratings from 401 partners, their subordinates and clients were used to test a proposed
model of leadership effectiveness in professional service firms. Correlations support four
of the five hypotheses. Path analyses results show that influence tactics and role
conflict mediate the relationship between partners leadership dispositions and
clients satisfaction with services provided.
94-26
Effects of Leadership Style and Followers Cultural Values on
Performance
Dong I. Jung, San Diego State University
Bruce J. Avolio, SUNY-Binghamton
The purpose of this study was to examine the impact of different leadership styles,
task structure and cultural values on performance. Transformational leadership increased
followers motivation and performance both at individual and group levels, especially
among collectivistic Asian-American participants. Implications for future cross-cultural
leadership research are discussed.
94-27
Personality Correlates of Perceived Senior Executive Effectiveness:
Application of the Five Factor Model
Robert Kaiser, Kaplan DeVries
Senior corporate leaders (N = 32) Adjective Checklist scores were
correlated with reliable self-, superior, peer, and subordinate ratings of global
effectiveness (Multiple Rs around .60). Analyses were interpreted within the
Five Factor Model of personality structure. The results raise provocative issues
challenging basic assumptions about senior management in large corporations.
94-28
A Meta-analytic Review of the Traits Associated with Leader Emergence
Michael J. Keeney, University of Akron
Christopher Marchioro, University of Akron
The methodology by which Lord, De Vader, and Alliger (1986) concluded that leaders can
be identified through differences in individual characteristics has been criticized. We
re-analyzed and extended Lord et al., producing more accurate population estimates for
intelligence, extroversion, adjustment, and dominance. Self-monitoring was found to be
related to leadership.
94-29
The Effectiveness of Orientation Training for Socializing New Hires
Howard J. Klein, Ohio State University
Natasha Weaver, Ohio State University
This field study examined the impact of attending a voluntary orientation training
program on socialization. Results for a matched sample of 126 employees revealed that
program attendees scored significantly higher on three of six socialization content
dimensions. Those six dimensions, in turn, related to role clarity, satisfaction, and
organizational commitment.
94-30
Use of Appropriate Referent in Multi-Level Climate Research
Stephanie R. Klein, Pennsylvania State University
John E. Mathieu, Pennsylvania State University
The authors surveyed 576 employees in 87 work groups at 39 organizations regarding
climate perceptions at three levels: individual, work group, and organization. Hypotheses
predicting that employees would identify different climates at different levels were
largely supported by both unaggregated and aggregated data. Issues regarding multi-level
organizational research are discussed.
94-31
Empowering Leadership, Transformational Leadership, and Feelings of
Empowerment: A Multi-Level Analysis
Amy M. Larmore, Illinois Institute of Technology
Roya Ayman, Illinois Institute of Technology
Relationships are examined with data on a sample of 52 Chief Executive Officers (CEOs)
and 217 direct reports. Results demonstrated that CEOs and their direct reports did not
agree upon perceptions of CEO empowering leadership. Within and between analysis indicates
that perceptions of leader behavior were based primarily on individual differences.
94-32
The Effect of Leaders Values on Group Citizenship
Jared D. Lock, Jeanneret & Associates
Laura E. Thomas, Texas A & M University
This study examined the relationship between leaders values and their
groups adherence to the organizations vision and whether they were fired.
Leaders and subordinates from a small insurance provider completed a measure of values
group citizenship, respectively. Results indicate significant relationships for some
values. Implications for organizations are discussed.
94-33
Leading Diverse Teams: The Impact of
Demographic Diversity, Cognitive Diversity
Kevin B. Lowe, Florida International University
K. Galen Kroeck, Florida International University
The relationship between leadership behavior, team diversity, and team processes to
eight team performance measures was tested. In intact teams, cognitive diversity had
several impacts on team processes/outcomes, demographic diversity had few impacts.
Demographic diversity did and cognitive diversity did not, moderate the leadership to team
process relationship.
94-34
A Model of Effectiveness of Downward Influence Tactics in Organizations
D. Lyakhovistky, SUNY at Albany
A model of the effectiveness of downward influence tactics (ITs) is suggested. ITs are
assumed to differ in the degree of their restrictiveness. The perceived restrictiveness of
the superior is determined by the ITs used and determines the reactions of the subordinate
moderated by the subordinates desire for control.
94-35
Does Supervisory Mentoring Add Value? A Five-year Investigation
Laura L. Paglis, Purdue University
Stephen Green, Purdue University
Talya N. Bauer, Portland State University
The impact of supervisory mentoring on protg productivity, career commitment, and
self-efficacy was assessed in a longitudinal study spanning 5 years. Positive results
were found for the influence of mentoring on subsequent productivity and self-efficacy.
Mentoring was not significantly associated with later career commitment.
94-36
A Meta-Analysis of Relationships Between Climate Perceptions
and Work Outcomes
Chris P. Parker, Northern Illinois University
Scott A. Young, Northern Illinois University
Rob Altmann, Northern Illinois University
Boris B. Baltes, Northern Illinois University
Joseph Huff, Northern Illinois University
Heather A. LaCost, Northern Illinois University
A meta-analysis of the organizational climate literature revealed significant
relationships between employees perceptions of their work environment and their work
attitudes, psychological well-being, motivation, and performance. Structural equation
modeling analyses indicate that the relationship of climate with employee motivation and
performance is fully mediated by employee work attitudes.
94-37
Bridging the Climate-Outcome Gap:
An Investigation of Service Employee Behaviors
Michelle C. Paul, University of Maryland
The organizational climateorganizational outcome relationship was conceptualized
as one that is mediated by employee behavior. The present study was specifically concerned
with the service climateservice quality relationship as mediated by customer-focused
employee behavior. Using employee and customer data from 16 hotels, general support was
found for employee behavior as a mediator of the climateoutcome relationship.
94-38
Work-Force Diversity Effects on Organizational Climate Quality and
Strength
W. Grant Pierce, NCS/London House
Roya Ayman, Illinois Institute of Technology
This study investigated the relationship between work place diversity and the strength
and quality of organizational climate at 100 retail stores. Results revealed a significant
relationship between tenure diversity and organizational climate quality. Tenure diversity
and demographic diversity variables were significantly related to different dimensions of
organizational climate strength.
94-39
Furthering our Understanding of Willingness to Relocate
Cynthia A. Prehar, Colorado State University
A new model of relocation decisions was tested in a sample of 205 working MBA
graduates. Attitudes toward relocating and perceived social pressures explained over 50%
of the variance in willingness to relocate. By moving beyond demographic research, the
results further our understanding of relocation behavior.
94-40
Leadership Style, Change, and Stress Resiliency From the Leaders
Perspective
Mark T. Rohricht, University of Tennessee
Michael C. Rush, University of Tennessee
The purpose of this research was to investigate how stress, pressure of change, and
hardiness relate to transactional and transformational leader behaviors. Findings suggest
that stress and pressure of change relate differently to leader behaviors and that
hardiness and stress are related both directly and interactively to certain leader
behaviors.
94-41
Relationship Between LMX and Subordinate Health Outcomes
Under Varying Conditions
Mark Rose, University of South Florida
Carnot E. Nelson, University of South Florida
The relationship between LMX and various stress-related outcomes was examined. Results
showed that LMX was positively related to job satisfaction, and negatively related to Type
A impatience-irritability, burnout, and medical problems. Further, task analyzability and
various individual needs (e.g., growth need strength) moderated some of these
relationships.
94-42
Reliability of Autonomy Scales: A Meta-Analysis
Nila Sinha, Florida International University
Chockalingam Viswesvaran, Florida International University
A meta-analysis was conducted on reliability coefficients reported for autonomy scales.
Ninety-nine samples were analyzed (N = 45,124; M = .69). Reliabilities for
managerial, nonmanagerial, and heterogeneous samples were separately analyzed. No
differences existed between overall and heterogeneous samples. Nonmanagers possessed the
largest estimates. Implications for the future of autonomy study and organizational
behavior are discussed.
94-43
Predictors of Advancing in Management at Three Points
Phyllis Tharenou, University of Queensland
Managerial advancement was predicted by different factors at three transition points.
Important for entry to management were career tournament wins, managerial traits, and
gender-linked social factors; for lower to middle manager advancement, traits,
gender-linked social factors, promotion opportunities, and human capital; and for middle
to upper manager, challenging work and male hierarchies.
94-44
Attributional Complexity: A Link Between Decision Latitude,
LMX, and Performance
Joellyn Townsend, University of Houston
Nancy Dasilva, University of Houston
Lorin Mueller, University of Houston
Pat J. Curtin, University of Houston
Lois E. Tetrick, University of Houston
Attributional complexity (AC) was related to job performance and decision latitude but
not to leader-member exchange (LMX). Contrary to expectations, social and task complexity
of jobs did not moderate these relations. Results suggest that experience making decisions
gained from having a high LMX leads to higher AC and performance.
94-45
Converging Evidence of Horizontal and Vertical Individualism and
Collectivism
Harry C. Triandis, University of Illinois
Michele J. Gelfand, University of Maryland
While the utility of the individualism and collectivism constructs has been widely
documented, there is the tendency to conceive of them as pure dichotomies. Four studies
examine an additional attribute that further defines the constructs, and demonstrates that
both constructs may be horizontal (emphasizing equality) or vertical (emphasizing status).
94-46
Determinants of Organizational Culture Impressions Among Job Seekers
Michael Wesson, Michigan State University
Alison Barber, Michigan State University
Verbal protocol analysis was used to assess determinants of organizational culture
impressions among job seekers. Results suggest that respondents used a variety of sources
to assess organizational values and that industry/occupa-tion and recruitment practices
were the most frequently used sources. Suggestions for influencing applicant impressions
are offered.
94-47
Substance and Form: Self-monitoring, Purpose-in-Life,
and Charismatic Leadership
John J. Sosik, Pennsylvania State University-Great Valley
This research examined the effect of leader self-monitoring on follower ratings of
charismatic leadership of 64 managers. Results revealed that self-monitoring was
positively related to ratings of charismatic leadership in the overall sample. Moreover,
this relationship was found for managers with high purpose-in-life, but not for managers
with low purpose-in-life.
| 95. Symposium: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Governors |
Space. The Final Frontier: Enhancing Performance Through Workspace
Design
This symposium will present business, organizational and research perspectives to
clarify the factors behind the corporations increasing transition to the new
workspace environments (open space officing, hoteling, telecommuting, neighborhood
officing, virtual officing, virtual teams, home officing, etc.) The presenters, senior
representatives of the key US organizations and organizational consultants, will discuss
the emerging workspace solutions and the subsequent organizational and performance
changes.
Ardeshir Mehran, Compass Management Solutions, Chair
Karen Lalli, The Hillier Group, Creating Team Spaces That Work: Trends,
Solutions and Case Studies
Ardeshir Mehran, Compass Management Solutions, Managing Cultural and Team
Attributes in Workspace
Redesign: Case Study
Presentation
Jim Lawler, Steelcase, Creating the Leadership Community: Enhancing
Executive Team Performance Through
Workplace Redesign
John Adams, Sun Microsystems, Collaborative Strategies for Enhancing
Workplace Effectiveness
Kathryn Goldman, Coherent Change Management, The Role of Executives, History
and Culture in Workspace
Transformation
| 96. Panel Discussion: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Miro |
High Performance Work Systems: Critical Issues of Definition,
Implementation and Outcomes
High performance work systems (HPWS), while not yet well defined in the literature,
involve field experiments with various human resource management strategies and ideal sets
of practices. Our panel examines theoretical approaches to high performance work systems,
implementation strategies, the impact on employees and firm performance, and future
research challenges.
Wendy S. Becker, Pennsylvania State University, Chair
Eileen Appelbaum, Economic Policy Institute, Peter Berg, Economic Policy
Institute, High Performance Work
Systems and the
Economics of Organizations
Gerald R. Ferris, University of Illinois, Gloria Harrell-Cook, University of
Illinois, David Kaplan, University of
Illinois, Human
Resource Management and Organizational Performance: Theory and Research
Challenges
Mark A. Huselid, Rutgers University, High Performance Work Systems: Impact
of Human Resource
Management Systems and
Strategic Alignment on Firm Effectiveness
Wendy S. Becker, Pennsylvania State University, Field of Dreams: Human
Resource Management Practices in
New Plant Start-ups
Edwin A. Locke, University of Maryland, Discussant
| 97. Roundtable: Saturday, 1:00 - 2:50
Wyeth |
Innovating Organizational Justice: Cultural, Value,
and Stakeholders Perspectives
The organizational justice area is ripe for theoretical innovation and the development
of new ideas. Directions for these ideas are provided through four themes: values,
culture, stakeholders, and new theoretical perspectives. With four simultaneous
roundtables followed by a general discussion, there will be ample opportunity for
initiating in-depth discussions that can alter the way we think about justice.
Dirk D. Steiner, Universit de Nice-Sophia Antipolis, Co-Chair
Stephen W. Gilliland, University of Arizona, Co-Chair
Russell S. Cropanzano, Colorado State University, Host
Daniel Skarlicki, University of Calgary, Host
Dianna L. Stone, SUNY at Albany, Host
M. Audrey Korsgaard, University of South Carolina, Host
Debra Shapiro, University of North Carolina, Discussant
| 98. Practitioner Forum: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Grand B |
Partnerships in Leading Strategic Organizational Change
The forum will present three examples of strategy-based partnerships between
corporations and consulting groups. The three papers will be co-presented and will
describe why and how each effort was designed, how they linked to strategy, and what the
results have shown. The discussant will encourage and lead audience participation.
Sandra L. Davis, MDA Consulting Group, Chair
Robert Barnett, MDA Consulting Group, Judy OHagan, Novartis Pharmaceuticals
Corp., Partnerships in
Merging Corporate
Culture
Robert F. Silzer, HR Assessment & Development, Roberta Douma, Capital One
Financial, Partnership on
Strategic Selection and
Development: Building a High Growth, High Technology Generation X
Company
Pierre G. Meyer, MDA Consultants, Lisa Shumpert, Mervyns California, Partnership
in Strategic Development
of Talent
P. Richard Jeanneret, Jeanneret & Associates, Discussant
| 99. Symposium: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Senators |
Utility Analysis: Acceptance and Implementation
The issues of utility acceptance and implementation appear to be at the forefront of
utility research. This symposium will focus on replications and extensions of Latham and
Whyte (1994), managerial views of ways to estimate SDy, the relationship
between rxy and rx$ and a model to guide acceptance
research.
Philip L. Roth, Clemson University, Chair
Kenneth P. Carson, University of Tennessee-Chattanooga, Chieh-Yu Lo, University of
Tennessee, The Utility of
Utility: A
Cross-Cultural Investigation
Michael K. Judiesch, Baruch College, CUNY, Using Estimation of SDr to Improve the Accuracy and User
Acceptability of
Utility Estimates
Craig J. Russell, University of Oklahoma, When rxy Does not Equal
rx$: An Application of Sensitivity Analysis
to the
Brogden-Cronback-Gleser Utility Model
Philip L. Roth, Clemson University, Albert Segars, University North Carolina,
Patrick M. Wright, Cornell
University, Developing
a Theoretical Model to Study Utility Analysis Acceptance
John W. Boudreau, Cornell University, Discussant
| 100. Panel Discussion: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Wedgwood |
Job Analysis for Teams: Fitting Square Pegs Into Round Holes?
The panel will address several issues related to team task analysis including research
needs, methodological requirements, use of results, and lessons learned. A primary topic
for discussion will be the extent to which tools and methodologies from job analysis can
be generalized to teams.
David P. Baker, University of Central Florida, Co-Chair
Eduardo Salas, Naval Air Warfare Center, Co-Chair
Michael A. Campion, Purdue University, Panelist
Janis Cannon-Bowers, Naval Air Warfare Center, Panelist
A. Catherine Higgs, Allstate Insurance Company, Panelist
Edward L. Levine, University of South Florida, Panelist
| 101. Symposium: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Metropolitan |
Elaborating the Nomological Network of Job Performance: Measurement,
Methods, and Evidence for Construct Validity
Estimating the construct validity of job performance calls for a multidimensional
approach that investigates interrelations among a wide range of job performance
components. In this symposium, empirical results are presented from investigations of four
different aspects of this job performance nomological network. The audience serves the
role of discussant.
Winfred E. Arthur, Texas A & M University, Chair
Chera L. Haworth, University of Akron, Paul E. Levy, University of Akron, Investigating
the Motivation Basis of
Organizational
Citizenship Behavior
Robert P. Tett, Wright State University, Angela Bleier, Wright State University,
Hal Guterman, Wright State
University, Patrick
Murphy, Wright State University, Support for Specificity in the Conceptualization of
Managerial Performance
David J. Woehr, Texas A & M University, Jeffrey S. Kane, Chinese University of
Hong Kong, Frequency-Based
Performance Assessment:
An Overview and Meta-analytic Review of the Accuracy of Frequency
Estimation
Judith M. Collins, Texas A & M University, Stepping Out on the
Performance Limb: Testing Campbells (1990)
Theory
Jack M. Feldman, Georgia Tech, Discussant
| 102. Symposium: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Monet |
Seasons of A Leaders Life: From Adolescence to Late Career
This symposium will focus on the seasons of leadership in organizations, beginning with
adolescence and progressing through the selection, mid-career, and late career of the
leader. Each participant will address a particular stage and explore issues relevant to
that season of leadership.
David P. Campbell, Center for Creative Leadership, Chair
George P. Hollenbeck, Hollenbeck Associates, A Moving Target: Seasonal
Changes in Selection of Leaders
David B. Peterson, Personnel Decisions International, Mary Dee J. Hicks, Personnel
Decisions International,
Coaching
Leaders at Mid-Career: Fewer Answers, Better Questions
Douglas T. Hall, Boston University, Succession and Mentoring Roles: The
Older Leader
Karen Holcombe, University of Maryland, Mark Ehrhart, University of Maryland,
Benjamin Schneider, University
of Maryland, Growing
Leaders: The Adolescent Years
David P. Campbell, Center for Creative Leadership, Discussant
| 103. Practitioner Forum: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Morocco |
Succession Management: Issues and Challenges in Identifying
and Developing Effective Leaders
Identifying and developing effective leaders is critical to organizational success.
Succession management provides a systematic approach by which to accomplish this. This
forum will provide a conceptual framework and key features of an effective succession
management system and will address the issues and challenges faced by practitioners in
various industries.
Ann Marie Yanushefski, Personnel Decisions International, Chair
Elaine Sloan, Personnel Decisions International, Claire Bender, Mayo Clinic,
Robert Blomberg, Mayo Clinic,
Developing
Mayos Physician Leaders for the Twenty-first Century
John Tracy, SBC Communications, Impacting Executive Development to Meet
Companies Needs
Jeffrey J. McHenry, Microsoft Corporation, Succession Management Within a
High Velocity Environment
| 104. Special Event: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Obelisk A & B |
Town Meeting for the Regional and Local I-O Psychology Groups
Come and exchange ideas with other local groups, plan joint efforts, and discuss
support needed from SIOP. Current and newly appointed SIOP Professional Association
Affairs Subcommittee Chairs will attend.
Donna L. Denning, Host
| 105. Symposium: Saturday, 1:30 - 2:50
Rosetta |
Predicting, Training, and Motivating Safe Driving Behaviors
in Delivery Occupations
This symposium reviews the development and analysis of industry-based interventions to
promote safe driving among soft drink distributors and pizza deliverers as well as
presents the preliminary validation of predictors for safe driving in these occupations.
Research reports focus on goal setting and behavioral feedback to improve driving
practices.
Timothy D. Ludwig, Appalachian State University, Chair
Steven W. Clarke, Virginia Tech, E. Scott Geller, Virginia Tech, Amy Gershenoff,
Virginia Tech, Using
Self-Monitoring to
Improve the Driving Safety of Professional Drivers
Julie A. Caplinger, Center for Organizational and Health Behavior, Timothy D.
Ludwig, Center for Organizational
and Health Behavior,
Yasmin Benton, Center for Organizational and Health Behavior, Providing Pizza
Deliverers Normative
Feedback and Rewards for Safe Driving
Jay Biggs, Appalachian State University, Timothy D. Ludwig, Appalachian State
University, Shannon Reynolds,
Appalachian State
University, Proximal Versus Distal Goal Setting as a Safe Driving Intervention
Tori L. Terrizzi, Appalachian State University, Sandy Edwards, Appalachian State
University, Mary Mcinnis,
Appalachian State
University, Timothy D. Ludwig, Appalachian State University, Delivering Safely:
Multiple Predictors for
Selecting Safe Deliverers
Jason P. DePasquale, Safety Performance Solutions, E. Scott Geller, Virginia Tech,
Michael Rowe, Virginia Tech,
Larry Littleton,
Virginia Tech, Feedback or Feedforward? Optimal Training for Increasing Safe Driving
Behaviors
| Coffee Break: Saturday, 3:00 - 3:30
Near SIOP Meeting Rooms |
| 106. Poster Session: Saturday, 3:30 - 5:20
Chantilly East |
Diversity Issues, Decision Making, and Team Behaviors
106-1
Career-Related Variables and Planned Retirement Age:
Extension of Beehrs Model
Gary A. Adams, University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh
Relationships between three career-related variables and planned retirement age were
examined using a sample of older workers. Regression analysis indicated that career
commitment and occupational goal attainment related to planned retirement age after
personal and work-related variables were held constant. An interaction between career
commitment and goal attainment was supported.
106-2
A Cross-Level Examination of Factors Influencing
Union Commitment and Participation
Mark Agars, Pennsylvania State University
Amy Unkless, Pennsylvania State University
Paul Tesluk, Tulane University
A cross-level model is used to examine individual and union-level variables related to
commitment to and participation in a teachers union. Results (N = 1,256)
provide evidence for the importance of both individual and union-level factors. Especially
notable are observed relationships for factors under union control, such as union-level
socialization and communication.
106-3
Gender and Family Structure:
Effects on Perceived Relocation Commitment and Resistance
Tammy D. Allen, University of South Florida
Lillian T. Eby, University of Georgia
Shane Douthitt, University of Georgia
Carry Noble, University of Georgia
The effects of applicant gender, family type (single-earner, dual-earner), and family
status (child, no child) on perceived commitment to relocate geographically and expected
spouse resistance to relocation were investigated. Interactions among the gender and
family structure variables were revealed that may be used to help explain differences in
geographic relocation mobility opportunities.
106-4
Procedural Justice Perceptions of Peer and Managerial Appeal Systems
Shelley N. Baker, University of Akron
Rosalie J. Hall, University of Akron
Procedural justice perceptions of peer versus managerial grievance appeal systems were
compared. Peer appeal was rated significantly higher on justice dimensions of neutrality,
standing, trust, and anticipated favorable outcome. Justice perceptions positively
correlated with belief-in-a-just-world.
106-5
Cultural Differences in Attitudes Toward Peer Evaluation:
An Exploratory Study
K. Denise Bane, Baruch College
This study compared attitudes of 47 MBA students representing 15 countries toward using
peer evaluations as part of the course grade. It was hypothesized that cultural
differences would influence perceptions of distributive and procedural justice, punitive
value, and level of comfort evaluating the performance of others. Hypotheses were
partially supported.
106-6
An Investigation of the Career Woman/Career Man Stereotype
Gerald Bartlett, University of Akron
Corey E. Miller, University of Akron
Dennis Doverspike, University of Akron
Eric Olesen, Barrett & Associates
Cathleen Callahan, Barett & Associates
Gender stereotype theory is often applied in employment discrimination cases even
though research consistently finds little or no direct effects of gender on evaluations.
The current research examines the career woman stereotype and suggests a possible reason
why the bias predicted by lack of fit theories is not observed.
106-7
Predicting Perceptions of Quality Circle Effectiveness
and Commitment Using Lisrel
Suzanne R. Bennett, University of Tennessee
Larry Williams, Virginia Commonwealth University
A model of Quality Circle effectiveness was developed and tested using LISREL. Nine
variables were proposed to be related to Quality Circle effectiveness and commitment.
Perceived significance, peer support, and team process were related to both effectiveness
and commitment. Furthermore, problem solving skills were related to effectiveness, and
voluntary participation was related to commitment.
106-8
Test of a Model of the Union Contract Ratification Process
Dawn M. Borovsky, Wayne State University
James Martin, Wayne State University
A model of the union contract ratification process was developed, which explained 80%
of the variance in voting behavior. The results supported the hypothesis that the economic
costs of contract rejection, union representation of members interests, working
conditions, contractual information from the union, and bargaining issues affect
members voting behavior.
106-9
Employee Reprimands: Do Observers Fairness Perceptions
Change with Contrasting Information?
Larry Bunce, Kansas State University
Jeffrey Gibbons, Kansas State University
Ronald G. Downey, Kansas State University
Perceptions of fairness are important to the effective functioning of organizations,
yet research has typically ignored the fairness judgments of impartial observers. This
study shows that observers perceptions of fairness change when given contrasting
information. Care should be taken by supervisors to establish the facts before
reprimanding employees in public.
106-10
Personality and Role Variables as Predictors of WFC
Dawn S. Carlson, University of Utah
Time, strain, and behavioral-based conflict are three dimensions of work-family
conflict and are thought to have unique antecedents. To determine if this is the case,
both dispositional and situational factors are considered as predictors of these three
types of conflict. Results suggest that each of the types of conflict do have a unique set
of antecedents.
106-11
Intra-Group Differences in Majority Managers Ethnic Identity
and Self-Identification
Donna Chrobot-Mason, Xerox Corporation
In this study, the development of ethnic identity in majority managers was examined.
Results suggest intra-group differences in ethnic identity development and
self-identification with an ethnic group. Consequences for minority employees were also
examined. Implications for corporate diversity initiatives are discussed.
106-12
Leading Workers to Help Themselves: A Contingency Approach to
Cooperation
Jason A. Colquitt, Michigan State University
Raymond A. Noe, Michigan State University
Brian Janz, University of Memphis
The relationship between leadership and cooperation was examined in a team setting
using a contingency paradigm wherein leader, subordinate, and team context factors were
examined. Cooperation was shown to be an interactive function of leader participative
style, job satisfaction, and team context (e.g., identity, size, skill, and material
resources).
106-13
The Search for Ambivalent Sexism: A Comparison of Two Measures
Amy B. Conn, University of Maryland
Paul J. Hanges, University of Maryland
William P. Sipe, University of Maryland
Amy Salvaggio, University of Maryland
We compared the properties of two widely used sexism measures. Confirmatory factor
analyses supported the factor structure of the scales. The relationships between these
scales were explored to examine the empirical overlap of these scales. Our findings
suggest that both measures may tap certain aspects of ambivalent sexism.
106-14
Demographic Moderators in a Model of Work-Family Conflict
J. Philip Craiger, University of Nebraska at Omaha
R. Jason Weiss, University of Nebraska at Omaha
Adam B. Butler, University of Wisconsin, Green Bay
Research on work-family conflict (WFC) typically attempts to locate demographic
differences in the level of conflict experienced. We examined subgroup differences in the
relationships between WFC and its antecedents and consequences. Results revealed
significant differences by gender and marital status, suggesting that
"universal" models of WFC are inappropriate.
106-15
Social Information Processing and Sex Bias in Employee Selection
Deborah A. Danzis, High Point University
The interplay between stereotype and individuating information in selection was
examined by having subjects rate a male or female job applicant for a sex-typed job.
Subjects were given a small, medium, or large amount of individuating information. Results
showed that information amount had a significant effect on ratings.
106-16
Time Orientation and Decision Making Under Time Pressure
David N. Dickter, AT&T
Mary A. Roznowski, Ohio State University
Robert S. Billings, Ohio State University
Time orientation, an individual difference in the attention to time and the perception
that time is a scarce resource that must be conserved carefully, was hypothesized to
influence individuals responses to time-pressured decisions. Time orientation was
positively related to perceived time pressure and the use of time-saving decision
heuristics.
106-17
Glass Ceiling: Relationships with Stereotypes, Mentoring,
and Perceived Mobility Channels
Tina Elacqua, Central Michigan University
Terry A. Beehr, Central Michigan University
Curtiss P. Hansen, Lincoln National Corporation
Managers (N = 708) at a large insurance company in the Midwest completed an
anonymous questionnaire assessing employee attitudes about women at work. This study
provides further explanation for the role of stereotypes, mentoring, and perceived
mobility channels on the perception of glass ceiling. Implications for the findings are
discussed.
106-18
The Role of Power in Sexual Harassment
Alexis A. Fink, Old Dominion University
Debra A. Major, Old Dominion University
Power is widely believed to play a key role in sexual harassment (SH). This research
quantifies the role of social power in SH in a university sample of employees and
students. Power is shown to be related to SH and victim responses to SH. Coercive power
emerged as particularly important.
106-19
Justifications for Ratings of Old and Young Job Applicants
Lisa Finkelstein, Northern Illinois University
Kelly Higgins, Northern Illinois University
Margaret Clancy, Northern Illinois University
This study explored the content of managers written statements justifying their
ratings of an older or younger job applicants interpersonal skills, economic worth,
and likelihood of being interviewed. Age-related concerns were more often elicited in
rating the older applicant, and most of these concerns were related to economic concerns.
106-20
Examining Individual-Level and Group-Level Influences on Helping
Behavior
Mark B. Gavin, Oklahoma State University
Larry Williams, Virginia Commonwealth University
David A. Hofmann, Texas A & M University
The present study simultaneously investigated the influence of individual-level and
group-level antecedents on helping behavior directed at both coworkers and the supervisor.
Results supported the influence of variables at each level and highlight the importance of
considering not only the individuals but the groups role in helping.
106-21
A Cultural Perspective on Judgment Biases in Negotiation
Michele J. Gelfand, University of Maryland
Lisa Nishii, University of Maryland
Marianne Higgins, University of Maryland
Christopher McCusker, Yale School of Management
Alexandria Dominguez, University of Maryland
The dominant paradigm in negotiation research has largely ignored the cultural context
in which negotiations take place, and there is an implicit assumption that theories apply
universally. This research focuses on negotiator cognition, and illustrates that two
judgment biases, self-serving perceptions and fixed sum error, are attenuated in cultures
which promote interdependence.
106-22
Factors That Mediate Sex Bias in Leadership Perceptions
Paul J. Hanges, University of Maryland
William P. Sipe, University of Maryland
Amy B. Conn, University of Maryland
Marianne Higgins, University of Maryland
Bradford S. Bell, Michigan State University
Amy Salvaggio, University of Maryland
The present study focuses on biases in information processing and how these biases
contribute to womens lack of progression to top management positions. We look at the
effects of raters sexist attitudes and personality characteristics on their
perceptions of emerging male and female leaders.
106-23
The Impact of Mental Models on Team Performance:
Sharedness, Quality, or Both?
Tonia S. Heffner, University Tennessee - Chattanooga
John E. Mathieu, Pennsylvania State University
Janis Cannon-Bowers, Naval Air Warfare Center
Team members (N = 148) team and task mental models of a computer flight
simulation task were examined. Repeated measures regression revealed sharedness and
quality of team members mental models, indexed in relation to task and team experts,
influenced team process. Consistent with the I-P-O model, team process influenced team
performance.
106-24
Perceptions of the Members of Diverse Work Groups
Madeline E. Heilman, New York University
Brian Welle, New York University
To determine whether association with diversity initiatives inadvertently activate
stereotypes of women in work groups, an experiment was conducted in which subjects
provided ratings of members of a work group shown in a photograph. The gender composition
of a group and the rationale for how the group members were assembled were varied. As
expected, women were rated as less competent and less likely to emerge as the group leader
when they were in a group with a diversity-related rationale for assembly than when other
rationales were provided.
106-25
Individual Differences Effects on the Perception of Sexual
Harassment
William H. Hendrix, Clemson University
Justin D. Rueb, US Military Academy
Robert P. Steel, Air Force Institute of Technology
Work status, initiators sex, respondents sex, age, position power, success
status, and initiators attractiveness on the perception of sexual harassment was
investigated. Behaviors were perceived as more sexually harassing if the individual was
male, older, more successful, unattractive, and had higher position power. Males perceived
males as more sexually harassing than females. Females perceived both sexes as equally
harassing.
106-26
Effects of Advertised HR Practices on Attraction of Black Applicants
Scott Highhouse, Bowling Green State University
Sandra Stierwalt, Bowling Green State University
Peter D. Bachiochi, Bowling Green State University
Allison Elder, Bowling Green State University
Gwen G. Fisher, Bowling Green State University
Student members of a society for Black engineers (n = 1,019) were more attracted
to an organization that advertised team-based work instead of individual-based work,
described a compensation system that rewarded individual performance rather than group
performance, and had an identity-conscious (AA) versus identity-blind (EEO) promotion
policy.
106-27
Accuracy Decomposition and Team Decision Making:
Testing Theoretical Boundary Conditions
John R. Hollenbeck, Michigan State University
Jason A. Colquitt, Michigan State University
Daniel R. Ilgen, Michigan State University
Jeffrey A. LePine, Michigan State University
Jennifer Hedlund, Yale University
This study examined the implications of accuracy decomposition (Gigone & Hastie,
1997) for the multilevel theory of team decision making. It also tested the theorys
generalizability across different staff specialization levels. Results demonstrate that
the validity of the theory generalizes across specialization levels, but not across
different components of decision accuracy.
106-28
Affirmative Action Attitudes:
Beliefs About Targets, Actions, and Economic Effects
David A. Kravitz, Rice University
Ann Kim Nguyen, Rice University
Stephen Klineberg, Rice University
Christopher Lund, Rice University
Emery Fu, Rice University
Employed adults attitudes toward affirmative action were associated with
demographic variables, correlated negatively with expectations of strong actions and
harmful effects on company performance, and correlated positively with beliefs that the
target group suffered employment discrimination and had poor employment opportunities.
Identity of the target group did not affect attitudes.
106-29
Interfunctional Power and Perceptions of the Work Environment
Sabine Maetzke, University of Tennessee
Joyce E. A. Russell, University of Tennessee
Stephen Gaby, University of Tennessee
Richard Reizenstein, University of Tennessee
Joseph Rentz, University of Tennessee
The study demonstrates how different perceptions of power, at the interfunctional
level, influence workers perceptions of their own work environment. Of the five
power bases, coercive power is consistently related to a need to impose more environmental
control. Perceived organizational support is also investigated within this framework.
106-30
Individual Constructs Applied to Groups:
Different Aggregates Have Different Meanings
Claire Mason, University of Queensland
Mark Griffin, University of Queensland
This study contrasts two approaches to conceptualizing and measuring group-level
variables: the aggregate of an individual-focused measure versus aggregated perceptions of
a group-focused measure. Individual-focused aggregates displayed less within-group
agreement and a lower proportion of between-group variance. The two aggregates exhibited
different patterns of relationships with other variables.
106-31
Relationships Between Work Teams and "Complementary" HR
Practices
Melinda S. Mayfield, Purdue University
Michael A. Campion, Purdue University
Teams continue to be the major work design trend in organizations. This study explores
relationships between high-involvement practices like teams and traditional HR practices
like training, selection, and compensation. The associations discovered may suggest that
certain HR practices complement the use of teams.
106-32
Coping with Stress in Conflict Resolution:
Personality Moderators in Strategy Choice
Philip J. Moberg, Wayne State University
The present study examined the influence of job stress and personality on preference
for conflict resolution strategy. Analysis of variance revealed main effects for
personality, but none for stress level, and the presence of interaction effects,
suggesting that personality traits moderate the impact of job stress on strategy choice.
106-33
Traditional and Flexible Work Schedules and Employee Satisfaction
Alison S. OBrien, George Mason University
Wendy J. Casper, George Mason University
Louis C. Buffardi, George Mason University
Carol Erdwins, George Mason University
A survey of Federal Government employees was used to assess the impact of flextime,
compressed work schedules, and kinship responsibility on six work attitude scales. Overall
results suggest the attempt to find improved work attitudes when allowing employees to
engage in flexible work arrangements may be misdirected.
106-34
Individual Preferences for Teams: A Policy-Capturing Study
Daniel Ostgaard, University of Minnesota
Paul R. Sackett, University of Minnesota
Individuals preference for teams was examined through policy capturing. A set of
six personal, social, structural, and task characteristics, identified by subjects as
important to their preference, were used as cues. Results indicate that motivation of team
members is the most important characteristic in determining an individuals
preference for teams.
106-35
Access Discrimination Among College Graduates
With and Without Physical Disabilities
Elissa L. Perry, University of Illinois
Wallace Hendricks, University of Illinois
Emir Broadbent, University of Illinois
Physically disabled and nondisabled college graduates were surveyed about their work
experiences. Results revealed that disabled respondents reported significantly more access
discrimination than nondisabled respondents. In addition, the specific type of physical
disability influenced the extent of access discrimination experienced. The results are
presented and their implications are discussed.
106-36
Defining and Measuring Employees Identification With Their Work
Groups
Christine M. Riordan, University of Georgia
Elizabeth Weatherly, University of Georgia
The objective of this study was to develop a conceptually and methodologically sound
measure of employee identification with the work group. Using content analysis as well as
exploratory and confirmatory analyses, we found support for the measure and demonstrated
its relation to, yet distinction from, both group cohesiveness and communication.
106-37
Extending the Stepladder Technique: An Examination of Self-Paced Groups
Steven Rogelberg, Bowling Green State University
Matthew S. OConnor, Bowling Green State University
Self-paced four-person Stepladder groups (n = 26) were found to outperform
conventional groups (n = 26) on a problem solving task. Time spent in the last two
steps of the Stepladder process was positively related to group decision quality.
Furthermore, a proposed best member influence explanation for Stepladder group success was
supported.
106-38
The Effects of Information Unreliability on Judgment and Decision Making
William M. Rogers, Michigan State University
Effects of unreliability on judgment and decision making are examined using an
experimental task involving both multiple-cue probability learning and process-tracing
components. Results suggest reliability of information affects judgment, but revealed no
clear effects on decision making. Implications for future use of similar combined
experimental tasks are discussed.
106-39
Perceived Fairness of Maternity Leave Policies in a University Setting
Elizabeth L. Shoenfelt, Western Kentucky University
Sarah J. Leider, Western Kentucky University
Faculty rated scenarios depicting three decision-making methods representing levels of
procedural justice and five maternity-leave policy options. Methods that allowed more
participation were rated as more fair and resulted in greater willingness to support the
policy; policy options requiring less work from other faculty were rated as more fair.
Implications for organizational decision making are discussed in terms of procedural
justice.
106-40
Decoy Effects on Internal Promotion Decisions
Jerel Slaughter, Bowling Green State University
Evan Sinar, Bowling Green State University
Scott Highhouse, Bowling Green State University
This research examined the effect of a decoy candidate in a promotion decision-making
context. Results showed that manipulating the effects of an asymmetrically dominated,
inferior decoy led to a significant preference shift between two superior candidates.
Implications for job-finalist choice are discussed.
106-41
The Effects of Disability and Assistive Technology on Performance
Evaluation
Steven E. Stern, University of Pittsburgh-Johnstown
Stephanie Brandt, University of Pittsburgh-Johnstown
Donald A. Hantula, Temple University
This study investigated disability, assistive technology, and outcome on attributions
and performance appraisal ratings. Employees with mental disabilities were rated lower
than employees with physical disabilities or non-disabled employees. Technology made
employees appear to be more dependable and their performance unexpected, but lowered
attributions of effort when unsuccessful. Successful outcome was associated with higher
ratings overall.
106-42
Applicant Race and Job Status as Predictors of Employment Discrimination
Lathonia Stewart, Clemson University
Richard Perlow, Clemson University
Applicant race, job status, and the evaluators racial attitude were examined as
possible predictors of unfair selection decisions. While no differences in hiring emerged,
a three-way interaction on the confidence in the hiring decision variable was found. These
data suggest that unfair discrimination may operate in subtle ways.
106-43
Adult Attachment as a Moderator of Work-Nonwork Relationship
H. Canan Sumer, Middle East Technical University
Moderating effects of the self- and other models underlying adult attachment on the
worknonwork relationship were examined. Only the self-model moderated the
relationship. Work and nonwork were significantly positively related among those with a
positive self-model but were less strongly related or unrelated among those with a
negative self-model.
106-44
Conflict Strategies: Their Relationship to
Group Performance and Group Viability
Donna Maria C. Vigil-King, University of Tennessee
Michael C. Rush, University of Tennessee
The relationship between conflict-handling strategies, group conflict, and group
performance and viability was examined. Groups using a more integrative conflict-handling
strategy had higher levels of viability and performance than those using less integrative
strategies. Group conflict functioned as a suppressor variable in the relationship between
conflict-handling strategies and performance.
106-45
Gender Differences in Upward Feedback Program Scores Over Six Years
Alan G. Walker, First Tennessee Bank
Susan A. Walker, Federal Express
Data is presented demonstrating incremental improvements in subordinates ratings
of 218 managers in a major Southeast financial institution over 6 years. Score improvement
across the 6 years was found to be unrelated to manager gender as was score differences
within any given year. Implications for practitioners are discussed.
106-46
Gender and Negotiator Competitiveness: A Meta-Analysis
Amy Walters, DePaul University
Alice F. Stuhlmacher, DePaul University
Lia L. Meyer, DePaul University
The present study investigated, through meta-analysis, the stereotypical perception
that men are more competitive negotiators than women. The mean weighted effect size of 62
research reports indicated that women are slightly more cooperative in bargaining. This
finding was moderated by characteristics of the bargaining interaction and of the opposing
party.
106-47
The Relationship Between Cognitive Heterogeneity and
Quality of Group Decisions
Joe Yum, Louisiana State University
Eric P. Braverman, Louisiana State University
The relationships between task-related cognitive heterogeneity, demographic
heterogeneity, and the quality of group decisions were examined with a sample of 35
three-person groups. The results showed a significant relationship between task-related
cognitive heterogeneity and group member heterogeneity in terms of gender. Implications of
this finding are discussed.
106-48
Antecedents of Accurate Leader Utilization of Staff Information
in Decision-Making Teams
Jean Phillips, Rutgers University
Leader utilization of staff recommendations when a differential weighting strategy was
appropriate was investigated. Eighty-four leaders participated in a computerized task.
Staff past accuracy information was related to greater staff weighting accuracy. Although
positively related to staff weighting, staff judgment confidence information did not
improve leader weighting accuracy.
| 107. Symposium: Saturday, 3:30 - 5:20
Governors |
Closing the Revolving Door: Theories on Selection at the Top
This symposium is designed to outline the theoretical frameworks and guides that both
researchers and practitioners are using in the area of executive selection. The session
will outline commonalities, discrepancies, and outright contradictions between these
viewpoints and will provide impetus for the audience to discuss their views, what works
and what doesnt, and how to improve selection at the top.
Valerie Sessa, Center for Creative Leadership, Chair
Benjamin Schneider, University of Maryland, Executive Selection in Context
Valerie Sessa, Center for Creative Leadership, Richard J. Campbell, Center for
Creative Leadership, Robert Kaiser,
Kaplan DeVries, To
Look In or Out? Contextual and Procedural Distinctions Between Internal and
External Executive
Selection Decisions
Donald Nelson, Pfizer Pharmaceuticals Group, Selection or Anointment?
Filling Positions at the Top
Jan Greenwood, Heidrick and Struggles, Competency and Urgency: Changes in
Selection Practices
David DeVries, Kaplan DeVries, Inc., Facilitator
| 108. Practitioner Forum: Saturday, 3:30 - 4:50
Senators |
Understanding And Evaluating Integrity in Law Enforcement
Law enforcement officers continually encounter ethical dilemmas. This forum presents
the FBIs measurement of integrity in the testing and hiring process and its
inclusion in the training of Special Agents. Experts from the selection program,
background investigation, polygraph and ethics training units will review integrity as a
critical characteristic in law enforcement. Policies, data analyses and research efforts
will be discussed.
Kerrie Q. Baker, FBI, Chair
Elizabeth B. Kolmstetter, FBI, The Inverted U-Files: Hypothesizing a
Curvilinear Relationship Between
Integrity and Performance
Patrick Maloy, FBI, Behind the Scenes: Your Past Will Catch up to You
James Murphy, FBI, Down to the Wire: Truth or Consequences in Polygraph
Testing
Frank Perry, FBI Academy, Training Law Enforcement Ethics: Can Integrity Be
Trained?
Kerrie Q. Baker, FBI, Discussant
| 109. Symposium: Saturday, 3:30 - 5:20
Wedgwood |
Multiple Predictors, Situational Influences, and Incremental Validity
This symposium focuses on improving prediction of a selection system by (a) using
multiple predictors, (b) broadening the criterion domain to include contextual
performance, and (c) taking situational moderators of predictor-criterion relationships
into account. A diverse set of perspectives on improving prediction will be presented,
including contrarian ones.
Deniz S. Ones, University of Minnesota, Chair
Miquel Quiones, Rice University, Roman Longoria, Rice University, The
Relationship Between Work
Experience and Job
Knowledge: A Theoretical and Empirical Reexamination
Chockalingam Viswesvaran, Florida Inte |