Jenny Baker / Monday, June 29, 2020 / Categories: 581 I-O Can Has Meme? Using Memes to Engage Others With I-O Psychology Content William P. Jimenez, Old Dominion University; Lisa M. Kath, San Diego State University; Sayeedul Islam, Farmingdale State College/Talent Metrics; and Gordon B. Schmidt, Purdue University Fort Wayne Author Note: The authors would like to thank Seterra D. Burleson and Ashlyn Frassinelli for their helpful recommendations during the development of this project. Memes are ubiquitous, and they have become a major part of online interactions (Kitchener, 2018). Memes may be an accessible medium that organizations can use to connect with potential employees, customers, and the general public. Not only have memes been used by companies for marketing (e.g., Murray et al., 2014), but they also have been used for outreach by organizations as diverse as academic libraries (e.g., Woodworth, 2018), government influence campaigns (e.g., Zakem et al., 2018), and political campaigns (e.g., Graham, 2020). In this paper, we discuss the current state of Internet memes in the I-O psychology community as well as the potential that memes have as a communication medium for the field’s outreach efforts. Indeed, one of the challenges that I-O psychology faces is its obscurity (Nolan et al., 2014; Gasser et al., 2001). We analyzed intentional efforts to share I-O psychology ideas on the @iopsychmemes social media accounts. We identified which memes garnered the most engagement with social media users and examined differences across Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. Additionally, we explored how those outside I-O on the popular website Reddit engaged with memes that reflect core I-O psychology concepts. The Reddit users who created and engaged with these memes are likely unconnected to our field, but their engagement with such memes suggests that they are interested in topics germane to I-O psychology and that they find such topics personally relevant. We examined Reddit users’ comments and incorporated topic modeling to uncover themes in conversations Reddit users were having regarding I-O-relevant memes. In both cases, we examined I-O psychology concepts that seem to resonate with these audiences so as to potentially inform future I-O psychology outreach efforts—especially with regard to reaching out to younger audiences, who are especially avid meme consumers (Fink, 2020) yet who have little direct exposure to our field. This paper’s thesis is that memes have the potential to be a valuable tool for I-O psychology’s outreach efforts. What exactly is a meme? Recent definitions of Internet meme from media and communication scholars include “a unit of information . . . , which replicates by passing on via Internet (e-mail, chat forum, social networks, etc.) in the shape of a hyper-link, video, image, or phrase” (Castaño Díaz, 2013, p. 97) and “a piece of culture, typically a joke, which gains influence through online transmission” (Davison, 2012, p. 122). Oftentimes, when Internet users share memes, they are not simply copying and pasting identical pieces of content (Börzsei, 2013). Many adapt others’ memes to express their own ideas—effectively creating new iterations of memes as a result (e.g., Figure 1). We begin with a personal account from the Meme Queen herself, our very own Lisa Kath, about her experience running the @iopsychmemes accounts—followed by an analysis of memes from Reddit. Initial Analyses of Engagement for @iopsychmemes My (Lisa Kath) high school senior taught me to make memes, and with encouragement from my graduate students, I made @iopsychmemes accounts on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook around November 11, 2019. I did some simple analyses on followers and posts from the start of the accounts until March 6, 2020 (approximately 4 months). My follower count over this time increased on average 2 followers/day on Facebook (281 total), 7.5 followers/day on Twitter (856 total), and 12 followers/day on Instagram (1,469 total). The Instagram account got an early bump in followers for being highlighted by another popular account: @orgpsych. I also got encouraging comments such as, “It’s like I found something I didn’t even know was missing” and “This ticks all the boxes. You’re doing a public service.” This seems to be a good indication of interest in the content. The majority of my Facebook and Instagram followers are women between the ages of 25–35 in the US, but 15% of my followers on Facebook are under 25, and 32% of my followers on Instagram are under 25 years old. This was great news, because, with Keaton Fletcher at Georgia Tech, I cochair the SIOP Visibility Committee’s Students and Academia subcommittee, where we aim to increase the visibility of I-O psych and SIOP to students and teachers. Based on advice I got from the aforementioned high school senior in my house, I include #APpsych in my captions to better reach high school students. Although I thought this memes account would be a brief hobby, I now conceptualize it as part of my SIOP service. Finally, first author Wil Jimenez and I analyzed the content of the posts. I took the top 10 memes (based on engagement metrics) from each platform (identified by date of posting) and indicated overlap using a Venn diagram. Wil came up with the coding of the content into three broad categories: posts that (a) share a tidbit of information from our field that we wish people would know, (b) celebrate/disparage some best/worst practices, and (c) note the relative obscurity of I-O psychology. Each of these is color coded in Figure 2 (see Figure 3 for examples of engaging memes). One observation that comes up right away is the relatively low overlap in high-engagement posts across the platforms, which may be old news to social media analysts. The low overlap may be an artifact of the way engagement is measured or the algorithms that place posts in viewers’ feeds. Another observation is that the earlier posts seemed to do better on Twitter, whereas more recent posts did better on Facebook. Popular Facebook posts had more overlap with Instagram and Twitter, whereas Twitter and Instagram only had one top 10 post in common. With the content coding, it seems that popular posts were relatively evenly spread across the three content categories. It would be interesting to see if there were demographic differences across the three content categories in terms of engagement. It would also be interesting to see if there were other ways of coding the content that would better predict engagement. For example, there are several ways in which meme templates are quantified in terms of their popularity or worth (Coscia, 2013). It is possible that some of these metrics could predict engagement based on the template alone. Not surprisingly, finding the right metrics to include in the model is a thought-provoking and time-consuming challenge. Takeaways From Managing @iopsychmemes Running the @iopsychmemes accounts has been a great adventure so far. I’ve been supported by several followers who will submit memes, and my graduate students and a colleague (Hi Lacie Barber!) have helped workshop memes before posting. But the question remains: Why? First, I am passionate about increasing the visibility of our field. I have anecdotal evidence (the worst kind, I know) that these accounts do help increase the visibility of I-O psychology. Through Twitter, we were invited to give a presentation at a neighboring high school, so now those students can be considering I-O psychology before they’ve even gotten their high school diplomas! I’ve had a few students, both high school and undergrad, reach out through the account direct messages for career advice. So far, the requests have been very manageable, but long term, our subcommittee is working with Roni Reiter-Palmon, chair of the SIOP Education & Training Committee’s Bridge Builders Subcommittee. We are working on building a database of I-O psychologists who might be willing to talk or email with students about our field, individually or in a group setting. Second, I love sharing what we (as I-O psychologists) know with others. I am collaborating on some research with an MD who follows my meme account. She told me that one of my memes came to mind at work, and she asked herself, “Is our diversity plan focused only on recruitment, or are we also paying attention to retention?” That memes can stick in people’s heads long enough for them to be useful to non-I-O psychologists is amazing to me. Third, I love supporting the broader I-O community. I have encouraged educators and practitioners to use these memes in their classes, newsletters, and the like. I also enjoy comments that indicate bonding over shared experiences, like how often we say “it depends” in response to a question (I-O Psych Memes, December 15, 2019) or the pain of having cross-loaded items in an exploratory factor analysis (I-O Psych Memes, February 20, 2020). In sum, so far, the minimal time invested in this outreach effort has been well worth it. I think the role of scientific communication in the sciences is starting to get its due, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Granted, I know I’m not out here saving lives with my spicy memes, but I do think it’s been a worthwhile adventure. I invite you to send me your memes at firstname.lastname@example.org or start your own accounts! In my mind, there’s never too much I-O psychology. Analyzing Comments on Work-Related Reddit Memes “IF YOUR EMPLOYEES HAVE TO BREAK RULES TO MEET PRODUCTION QUOTA YOU ARE MISMANAGING YOUR COMPANY” in a sans-serif font superimposed on a picture of a mallard duck. A still from a popular adult cartoon television series edited to look like a superhero is recommending that employers disclose salary ranges when they post job openings. This past winter, in just 1 week, these two images (see AcidActually, 2020; Elranzer, 2020) made it to “the front page of the Internet” and collectively garnered approximately 128,000 upvotes and 4,000 comments. These are examples of work-related memes posted on Reddit—specifically, on the subreddit r/AdviceAnimals—and they demonstrate how relatable I-O psychology is to laypeople. Reddit is a popular social media platform comprising a multitude of online communities of interest, called subreddits, in which users share and engage with content.1 In December 2019, Reddit was the fifth most visited website in the United States; it had more than 130,000 active subreddits and, on average, 430 million monthly active users and 21 billion monthly screen views (Reddit, 2019). According to Pew Research Center, most Redditors are male, White, between the ages of 18 and 29, and college educated (Barthel et al., 2016). The subreddit r/AdviceAnimals is a community with more than 8.4 million members (as of April 2020) who engage with memes generally in the format of a “two line joke over a re-usable character” (“Advice Animals,” n.d.). We used the PRAW Python package (Boe, 2016) to scrape top-level comments, which we processed and analyzed in R using data.table (Dowle & Srinivasan, 2019), textmineR (Jones, 2019), tidytext (Silge & Robinson, 2016), tidyverse (Wickham et al., 2019), and wordcloud (Fellows, 2018). Stopwords, punctuation, and numbers were removed from the comments, and each comment was tokenized as a maximum of two words. We used latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) in our topic modeling of the comments (see Blei et al., 2003).2 We also searched the comments for words that were most characteristic of a topic to aid in topic interpretation. Production Quota Meme’s Comments We found that extracting 29 topics from the production quota meme’s 432 top-level comments resulted in the greatest topic coherence (see Appendix A). Of these topics, we interpreted 15 with seven consolidated into a triad and two pairs—ultimately resulting in 11 retained topics. Multiple Redditors discussed the following: Topic 1: Reduced work quality Topic 2: Employees cutting corners Topic 3: Prevalence of phenomenon in sales jobs Topic 4: Examples of high-profile organizations that perpetrate the phenomenon Topic 5: Workers compelled to break not only rules, but also laws Topic 6: Employers discouraging or not allowing overtime work Topic 7: Employer apathy Topic 8: Employers intentionally encouraging employees to break rules and consequently making it easier to terminate rule-breaking employees Topic 9: Broken societal and managerial systems Topic 10: Prevalence of phenomenon in food service—in particular, fast food Topic 11: Employers’ disregard for employee health and safety Salary Meme’s Comments We found that extracting 27 topics from the salary meme’s 506 top-level comments resulted in the greatest topic coherence (see Appendix B). Of these topics, we interpreted 20, with seven consolidated into a triad and two pairs—ultimately resulting in 16 retained topics. Multiple Redditors discussed the following: Topic 1: Factoring benefits into compensation Topic 2: Being lowballed during interviews Topic 3: Feeling like not advertising salaries generally results in wasted time for both applicants (e.g., candidates offered uncompetitive salaries given their current ones) and employers Topic 4: Employers not advertising salary in job postings to prevent causing tension with current employees Topic 5: Skepticism over salaries advertised as “competitive” and annoyance with having to provide an “expected salary” on a job application Topic 6: Recruiters’ willingness to discuss salary during a phone interview Topic 7: The importance of knowing what you are “worth”/the market rate for a position Topic 8: Employees keeping their own salaries a secret Topic 9: Hiring managers’ perspectives Topic 10: Negative views toward recruiters Topic 11: Negative views toward employers who do not advertise salaries Topic 12: Negative views toward job openings advertised as “entry level” Topic 13: Recruiters’ justification that not advertising salaries results in better quality hires Topic 14: Salary being based on experience and skills Topic 15: Minimum wage and legal matters See Figure 5 for word clouds depicting the words that constitute the topics we retained in our analysis of the salary meme’s comments. r/AdviceAnimals Meme Topics in I-O Terms The topics that emerged from comments on both of the r/AdviceAnimals memes clearly overlap with I-O psychology topics. In this section, we discuss example topics from each of the memes. Topic 11 of the production quota meme indicates that, from the perspective of some Redditors, some companies are neglecting occupational health and safety when they are compelling employees to break rules for the sake of productivity. This is a poignant finding given that safety climate (i.e., shared perceptions regarding how much of a priority safety is compared to other priorities, such as productivity) seems to be a particularly important determinant of safe behavior—potentially even more so than the prevalence of occupational risks and hazards in the workplace (Nahrgang et al., 2011). Another example from the production quota meme is Topic 7, which suggests that some employers discourage or even prohibit employees from working overtime. Ironically, paying overtime work is generally more affordable than hiring more employees, and there is empirical evidence that suggests, on average, the more hours per week employees work at an organization, the lower the lost-time injury rate at the organization (Kaminski, 2001). Unsurprisingly, several of the example topics from the salary meme imply negative job applicant reactions. For example, Topic 3 indicates that some Redditors believe that the employer practice of not advertising salaries often results in wasted time. Topics 5 and 12 indicate that some Redditors react negatively when the job opening advertises a “competitive” salary or an entry-level position, yet the requirements listed suggest otherwise or a job application requires providing an expected salary. Our field understands the importance of applicant reactions in the context of personnel selection (see Bauer et al., 2012). For example, previous research suggests that positive reactions during the selection process impact applicants’ perceptions of the organization, intentions to accept a job offer, and intentions to recommend the employer to other job seekers (Hausknecht et al., 2004). Moreover, findings from a simulation study suggest that the level of information a job seeker receives, even during the initial recruitment stage, impacts applicant reactions and that the more favorable experiences an applicant has throughout the selection process, the more positive their reactions are (Saks & Uggerslev, 2009). Given the example salary meme topics that we discussed and the literature on applicant reactions, it would be prudent of employers to consider the impressions they are making through their job openings. Discussion The results of the present study indicate that there is an interest in I-O psychology topics beyond traditional settings. Memes and other social-media-related strategies are underused in I-O psychology outreach (Armstrong et al., 2020), and these results indicate their potential efficacy. The authors wish to share some key takeaways from this study: Memes are a highly useful tool for sharing information. The present study indicates that memes can prove engaging to a wide audience. Memes are exciting because they can be shared easily and created easily. We recommend that the I-O psychology community—academics, practitioners, and students alike—share these as a way to conduct outreach. Most importantly, anyone can share and anyone can create a meme, so crowdsourcing memes may be a useful form of outreach for I-O. Another application is asking students to share or create memes as part of a class assignment. I-O psychologists can join the conversation or just listen. The results from the r/Advice Animals subreddit analyses indicate that everyday people are interested in what I-O psychologists study. The gap appears to be in how I-O psychologists approach these topics. Memes can distill concepts into easily accessible formats that lay people can engage with. Additionally, these memes can provide insight into the experiences of everyday workers outside of the traditional practitioner realm of I-O. For I-O psychologists who are prominent in our field on social media, such as Adam Grant and Steven Rogelberg, memes might be another way in which they share the field with a general audience. As evidenced by the @iopsychmemes accounts, memes can also be used to build an active online community that laypeople can engage with online. Memes are measurable. Using the social media data from @iopsychmemes, practitioners and researchers can track the impact of I-O psychology on people inside and outside the field. This information is invaluable as SIOP and other organizations in the realm of work strive to be heard. We can also track how laypeople are discussing work on public forums such as Reddit—allowing for a more measurable “pulse” of the world of work. Memes are fun! Memes can inject a bit of fun into the world of I-O. The authors of the present study had enormous fun writing this piece and believe that other I-O psychologists would enjoy the fun world of memes as well. Notes 1 For more information on Reddit, see Gordon Schmidt’s (2019) entry in The SAGE International Encyclopedia of Mass Media & Society. 2 See Tang’s (2019) topic modeling guide that we adapted for analyzing Reddit comments. References AcidActually. (2020, January 28). You need to know [Image attached] [Online forum post]. Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/AdviceAnimals/comments/ev7zh7/you_need_to_know/ Advice Animals. (n.d.). In Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/AdviceAnimals/ Armstrong, B., Schmidt, G. B., Islam, S., Jimenez, W. P., & Knudsen, E. (2020). Searching for I-O psychology: How practitioners, academics, and laypeople engage with the I-O brand online. The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist, 57(3). https://www.siop.org/Research-Publications/Items-of-Interest/ArtMID/19366/ArticleID/3300 Barthel, M., Stocking, G., Holcomb, & Mitchell, A. (2016). Nearly eight-in-ten Reddit users get news on the site. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/8/2016/02/PJ_2016.02.25_Reddit_FINAL.pdf Bauer, T. N., McCarthy, J., Anderson, N., Truxillo, D. M., & Salgado, J. F. (2012). What we know about applicant reactions to selection: Research summary and best practices (SHRM-SIOP White Paper Series). Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology. https://www.siop.org/Portals/84/docs/SIOP-SHRM%20White%20Papers/SIOP-Applicant_Reactions_to_Selection_final.pdf Blei, D. M., Ng, A. Y., & Jordan, M. I. (2003). Latent Dirichlet allocation. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 3, 993–1022. http://www.jmlr.org/papers/volume3/blei03a/blei03a.pdf Boe, B. (2016). PRAW [Python package]. https://github.com/praw-dev/praw Börzsei, L. K. (2013). Makes a meme instead: A concise history of Internet memes. New Media Studies Magazine, 7. https://works.bepress.com/linda_borzsei/2/ Castaño Díaz, C. M. (2013). Defining and characterizing the concept of Internet meme. CES Psicología, 6, 82–104. http://www.scielo.org.co/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S2011-30802013000200007 Cheezburger. (n.d.). In Know your meme. https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/sites/cheezburger Coscia, M. (2013). Competition and success in the meme pool: A case study on quickmeme.com. Proceedings of the Seventh International AAAI Conference on Weblogs and Social Media, 100–109. https://www.aaai.org/ocs/index.php/ICWSM/ICWSM13/paper/view/5990/6348 Davison, Patrick. (2012). The language of (Internet) memes. In M. Mandiberg (Ed.), The social media reader (pp. 120-134). NYU Press. Dowle, M. & Srinivasan, A. (2019). Data.table: Extension of “data.frame.” The Comprehensive R Archive Network. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/data.table/index.html Elranzer. (2020). Job recruiters and human resources, this means YOU [Image attached] [Online forum post]. Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/AdviceAnimals/comments/ezdk46/job_recruiters_and_human_resources_this_means_you/ Fellows, I. (2018). Wordcloud: Word clouds. The Comprehensive R Archive Network. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/wordcloud/index.html Fink, J. L. W. (2020, February 6). The role of memes in teen culture. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/06/well/family/memes-teens-coronavirus-wwiii-parents.html Gasser, M., Butler, A., Anderson, K., Whitsett, D., & Tan, R. (2001). Advertising industrial-organizational psychology. The Industrial-Organizational Psychologist, 38(4), 50–53. Graham, M. (2020, February 13). How Mike Bloomberg’s meme blitz was engineered to go viral. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/13/how-mike-bloombergs-meme-blitz-was-engineered-to-go-viral.html Hausknecht, J. P., Day, D. V., & Thomas, S. C. (2004). Applicant reactions to selection procedures: An updated model and meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 57, 639–683. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.2004.00003.x I-O Psych Memes [@iopsychmemes]. (2019, December 15). I-O psychologists learn systems thinking, which means we see many links among org, team, & individual factors. Therefore, when asked a [Image attached] [Tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/iopsychmemes/status/1206197515932049408/ I-O Psych Memes [@iopsychmemes]. (2019, December 20). OK, so we aren’t the most well-known field, but gosh darn it, we are doing good stuff for the world of work. [Image attached] [Tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/iopsychmemes/status/1208009437312667649 I-O Psych Memes [@iopsychmemes]. (2020, January, 11). Not all personality tests are the same, and the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) is a persistently popular one that I-O [Image attached] [Tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/iopsychmemes/status/1215981835710279680 I-O Psych Memes [@iopsychmemes]. (2020, February 20). 1-O psychologists work hard to test that their survey measures are working well, and sometimes the test results are dishearteningly complicated [Image attached] [Tweet]. Twitter. https://twitter.com/iopsychmemes/status/1230477589841575938 Jones, T. (2019). textmineR: Functions for text mining and topic modeling. The Comprehensive R Archive Network. https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/textmineR/index.html Kaminski, M. (2001). Unintended consequences: Organizational practices and their impact on workplace safety and productivity. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 6, 127–138. https://doi.org/10.1037/1076-89220.127.116.11 Kitchener, C. (2018, January 18). How memes became the voice of a generation. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/membership/archive/2018/01/how-memes-became-the-voice-of-a-generation/550805/ Murray, N., Manrai, A., & Manrai, L. (2014). Memes, memetics and marketing. In L. Moutinho, E. Bigné, & A. K. Manrai (Eds.), The Routledge companion to the future of marketing (pp. 331-347). Routledge. Nahrgang, J. D., Morgeson, F. P., Hofmann, D. A. (2011). Safety at work: A meta-analytic investigation of the link between job demands, job resources, burnout, engagement, and safety outcomes. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96, 91–94. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021484 Nolan, K. P., Islam, S., & Quartarone, M. (2014). The influence of vocational training on the brand images of organizational consultants. Psychologist-Manager Journal, 17, 245–278. https://doi.org/10.1037/mgr0000022 Reddit. (2019, December 4). About. https://www.redditinc.com Saks, A. M., & Uggerslev, K. L. (2009). Sequential and combined effects of recruitment information on applicant reactions. Journal of Business and Psychology, 25, 351–365. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10869-009-9142-0 Schmidt, G. B. (2019). Reddit. In D. Merskin (Ed.), The SAGE international encyclopedia of mass media & society. Sage. https://sk.sagepub.com/reference/the-sage-encyclopedia-of-mass-media-and-society/i14003.xml Silge, J., & Robinson, D. (2016). tidytext: Text mining and analysis using tidy data principles in R. Journal of Open Source Software, 1(3). https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.00037 Tang, F. (2019). Beginner’s guide to LDA topic modelling with R: Identifying topics within unstructured text. Towards Data Science. https://towardsdatascience.com/beginners-guide-to-lda-topic-modelling-with-r-e57a5a8e7a25 Wickham, H., Averick, M., Bryan, J., Chang, W., D’Agostino McGowan, L., Francois, R., Grolemund, G., Hayes, A., Henry, L., Hester, J., Kuhn, M., Pederson, T. L., Miller, E., Bache, S. M., Müller, K., Ooms, J., Robinson, D., Seidel, D. P., Spinu, V., . . . Yutani, H. (2019). Welcome to the Tidyverse. Journal of Open Source Software, 4(43). https://doi.org/10.21105/joss.01686 Woodworth, A. (2018). My body is ready: Best practices for using memes on library social media. Reference & User Services Quarterly, 58(2). https://doi.org/10.5860/rusq.58.2.6928 Zakem, V., McBride, M. K., & Hammerberg, K. (2018). Exploring the utility of memes for U.S. government influence campaigns. CNA. https://www.cna.org/CNA_files/PDF/DRM-2018-U-017433-Final.pdf Print 1782 Rate this article: 4.8 Comments are only visible to subscribers.