Home Home | About Us | Sitemap | Contact  
  • Info For
  • Professionals
  • Students
  • Educators
  • Media
  • Search
    Powered By Google

I-O Psychology’s Lack of Research Integrity

By Sheila K. List and Michael A. McDaniel, Virginia Commonwealth University

In recent years, the integrity of our scientific research has been called into question by the popular press who has asked if the scientific method is flawed (Lehrer, 2010). This assertion has been examined by many researchers as well (e.g., Bedeian, Taylor, & Miller, 2010; Kepes & McDaniel, 2013; O’Boyle, Banks, & Gonzalez-Mulé, in press). These authors have argued that the current states of I-O psychology and management are flawed for several reasons. First, the theory fetish (Hambrick, 2007) in our field is making it nearly impossible to publish null results or replications, which has prevented us from developing solid theory (Cucina & McDaniel, 2016). Second, for academics, the necessity to publish for tenure, retention, promotion, raises, and so on encourages researchers to engage in questionable research practices (QRPs) if the obtained results do not align with a priori expectations or do not reach statistical significance (e.g., Banks, Rogelberg, Woznyj, Landis, & Rupp, 2016; O’Boyle et al.).…Continue reading in the recent issue of TIP!


SIOP News  Items of Interest  Featuring... 

SIOP Election Results

SIOP Welcomes New Officers!

The results of the recent election are in, and SIOP’s newest Executive Board officers are:

Talya Bauer -President-Elect
Lori Foster - Communications Officer
Eden King - Conferences & Programs Officer
Steve Kozlowski - Research & Science Officer...Read more

I-O Flowchart
New Website Tool Provides Career Planning Guidance The Careers Study Subcommittee of SIOP’s Professional Practice Committee (PPC) has just published a Read more...
 
Diversity Is Good For Business
Male Champions Can Be Change Agents for Women’s Leadership Although women are seeing greater progress in reaching upper management levels in Read more...
 
View Items

‘Tis the Season for Making a Year-End Donation to the SIOP Foundation

Your tax-deductible gift to the SIOP Foundation will ensure ongoing funding for research, awards for excellence, and financial support for outstanding doctoral students. Please consider making a donation now while doing your year-end tax planning....Read more